Sunday, October 5, 2014

Hunkering Down

The crowd of protesters remained strong on Sunday morning
Jeff and I received an email late last week asking if the pro-democracy protests had us 'hunkered down.'  Our apartment and my office are far enough away from protest areas to leave us relatively undisturbed by events.  The most significant consequence has been minor inconvenience due to diversion or suspension of public buses.  We are following developments closely and feel privileged to have a front row seat to democracy in action and history in the making.
Protesters remain remarkably upbeat despite living outside
in  Hong Kong's incessant heat, humidity and thunderstorms
The pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong are entering the eighth day.  Last Wednesday and Thursday were public holidays in Hong Kong, limiting their impact.  However, with the beginning of a "normal" work week approaching tomorrow, Hong Kong Chief Executive C.Y. Leung  warned ominously of "tragedy" unless protesters disperse.  He specifically identified the need for schools to reopen and Hong Kong's civil servants to return to their offices, which have been blocked  by protesters for the past several days.  Leaders of the protests indicate they will allow civil servants to pass through protest areas so that they can reach their offices.
China's insistence on screening candidates for Hong Kong's
Chief Executive and legislative roles is the heart of the issue

The week has featured disruption, relentless press coverage and even a protest-zone marriage proposal:

A protest banner hanging from an overpass
Many insights and stories have emerged from the extensive media coverage of the protests:
  • The PRC views the extent of its commitment to universal suffrage differently than other governments, particularly Britain, with whom they ratified the joint declaration in 1984.
  • In the 17 years since the 1997 handover, Hongkongers have waited patiently for the PRC to deliver.  Much of the world, including three former U.S. Consul Generals, want Beijing to pick up the pace.
  • The use of tear gas and pepper spray on students demonstrating peacefully doesn't make a good impression or earn any international goodwill.  Both the U.S. and the UK have expressed diplomatic concern.
  • For the PRC government to claim that the protests are strictly "China's internal affairs" seems  disingenuous given that the heart of the issue was a key principle of returning Hong Kong to Chinese rule. 
  • Umbrellas, goggles, surgical masks and plastic wrap --  makeshift defense against tear gas and pepper spray -- have become potent symbols for the movement.
  • The Chief Executive of Hong Kong, C.Y. Leung, has proven himself to be more a man of Beijing than a man of the people.
  • Even peaceful civil disobedience can have unintended consequences.
  • Keeping up with your homework, picking up trash and recycling in the protest zone helps a cause garner international support.
  • Ultimatums and deadlines don't need to have serious consequences.
  • In such a public battle, a wily adversary will employ any means possible to gain advantage.
  • Mainland China gets a very different version of the story from what is reported in Hong Kong.
Rain or shine, umbrellas are ubiquitous in the protest sites
Organization among the protesters is strong, and
mobile phones are critical for communication
The protesters now appear to be hunkering down, while the government has set a deadline of Monday morning for the protesters to disperse and clear the roads.  Over the past week, as tensions have risen and dropped, scuffles have broken out and been diffused, and deadlines have come and gone, the one thing that all parties seem to agree on is a desire to avoid more tear gas and associated violence.  We think that the Chinese government has the opportunity to prevent this by acknowledging and expressing a willingness to close the gap between their obligation and Hong Kong's expectations for electoral reform.  
Sloganeering with packing tape, magic markers and cardboard

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

Politely Protesting the People's Republic

Umbrellas are used as shields from pepper spray and
have become a symbol of the pro-democracy movement
Over the past few days, Jeff and I have heard from many of our friends and family, asking if we are safe given the pro-democracy protests going on in Hong Kong.  We are grateful for the concern expressed and happy to report that we are safe and relatively unaffected by the events.  Today is National Day, a public holiday to celebrate the 1949 founding of the People's Republic of China (PRC).  Despite the day off work, National Day doesn't seem like a particularly joyous occasion for most Hongkongers.

The word "complicated" doesn't begin to describe today's governance and politics in Hong Kong.  Between 1843 and 1997, Hong Kong was led by a Governor appointed by the British Monarch. There were 28 Hong Kong Governors, typically career diplomats, and we see many of their names on street signs and buildings around the city today.  Upon the handover of Hong Kong to the PRC in 1997, the role of Governor was replaced by a Chief Executive who assumed responsibility for the civil functions, while responsibility for the military functions was transferred to the Commander of the People's Liberation Army Hong Kong Garrison.
Although Britain indefinitely controlled Hong Kong Island and Kowloon,
its control over the New Territories ceased on June 30, 1997
Thousands of protesters peacefully occupy and block
several major roads around Hong Kong

Britain's control over the 3 territories of Hong Kong came about through a series of treaties, the last of which was ratified in 1898.  Although Britain had rights to control Hong Kong Island and the Kowloon Peninsula indefinitely, the treaty of 1898 was a 99 year lease over the New Territories, expiring on June 30, 1997.  Throughout the lease, no attempt was made to segregate the New Territories from the other two Hong Kong territories.  Infrastructure, business and society were allowed to develop on an integrated basis across the territories, to the point where separating the New Territories became impractical.
Most of the protesters are university students

In 1979, negotiations began between Britain and the PRC over the approaching lease expiration. These negotiations culminated in the handover on July 1, 1997.  A joint declaration outlined the two countries' intentions to transfer power over Hong Kong in 1997, along with the basic policies by which the PRC would govern Hong Kong as a Special Administrative Region under the "one country, two systems" principle.  These policies were codified as Hong Kong Basic Law, a constitutional document that prohibits socialism and preserves capitalism and the existing way of life in Hong Kong for at least 50 years, or until 2047.

Basic Law assures that Hong Kong will (1) be governed by local inhabitants; (2) have a great deal of autonomy; and (3) elect officials "ultimately by means of universal suffrage."  The ambiguity of when Hong Kong can expect true
Supplies for a protest:  Face masks, plastic wrap, bottled water and bananas
universal suffrage is at the heart of the protests.  Since the handover, the Chief Executive has been selected by a committee whose members are chosen from Beijing.  Finally, in 2007, Beijing announced that Hong Kong would directly elect the Chief Executive  in 2017, followed in 2020 by direct elections for the legislature.  But the "direct" elections come with a caveat: candidates for office must be approved by Beijing to ensure that they "love China."
Police barricade the Central Government Offices and
the Legislative Council Complex
The screening of candidates by the PRC is the hot button for the pro-democracy groups, who have generally been dissatisfied with the pace of electoral reform in Hong Kong since the handover.  It's not difficult to understand why when you consider the caliber of Chief Executives appointed by the PRC since the handover.
Universal suffrage is at the heart of the protest movement
Normally bustling, Des Voeux Road Central is empty at mid-day on Tuesday
Today marks the fourth day of the protests. The impact has been significant: roads closed, public transit disrupted and some businesses unable to operate (click here to see an amazing video of the protest areas by the BBC).  The spectacle of tear gas and pepper spray was fortunately limited to the first night, after which the riot police were pulled from the streets.  As the number of protesters has grown each day, their organization, resolve and commitment to a peaceful demonstration has strengthened.  The groups are even collecting trash and recyclables from protest areas.  The Chinese government has found itself in an awkward spot as it celebrates the 65th anniversary of the PRC.  The rest of the world is watching while the Chinese weigh their options of compromising ideology versus forcibly removing a peaceful, sympathetic and even polite group whose goal is the open elections they have been promised.
Yellow ribbons have become a symbol of the protest